PeaceVerse Grades 9-12 Phase 3 Story Design Studio
My Dilemma Planning Sheet
Defining the moral and emotional conflict driving my manuscript chapter · Lesson 12
Grade
9, 10, 11 & 12
Format
Fillable Digital Sheet
Lesson Time
Author Studio · 45 min
Outcome
One Dilemma Statement
📝
Compelling stories often grow from a dilemma that exposes what a character values, fears, protects, or refuses to ignore. In this lesson, the task is to identify the central conflict that can sustain a meaningful chapter—one where the pressure is real, the stakes are credible, and the choice reveals who the character is becoming.
1
Generate Possible Conflicts
list 3–5 moments with tension, contradiction, or consequence
What is a dilemma?
A dilemma is not simply a setback. It is a conflict in which multiple values, loyalties, truths, or outcomes compete, and no choice is cost-free. This is often where character is most visible.
3–5 moments that could anchor a chapter
Consider moments involving ethics, identity, family pressure, friendship, justice, belonging, ambition, safety, silence, or responsibility.
Protecting someone and telling the truth were not the same choiceLoyalty conflicted with another valueSpeaking up could create both risk and changeEvery option carried a consequence
1
Moment One
What happened?name the pressure point
Why could it carry a full chapter?
2
Moment Two
What happened?name the pressure point
Why could it carry a full chapter?
3
Moment Three
What happened?name the pressure point
Why could it carry a full chapter?
2
Map the Stakes
what makes the conflict matter?
What emotions, values, or identities are in conflict?
Language Bank · Tap to collect words that fit
ambivalencebetrayalaccountabilityshameintegrityloyaltyfearsolidaritypowervulnerabilitydissonanceagency
What could be lost, changed, exposed, or protected?
State the actual dilemma as a choice
Try to name both sides clearly and honestly, without flattening the complexity.
3
Select the Conflict with the Most Narrative Power
which one is hardest, richest, and most revealing?
Choose the moment that opens the strongest questions: What does the character value? What are they willing to risk? What truth can no longer be avoided?
Why does this dilemma belong in your manuscript?
4
Interrogate the Conflict
use dialogue to deepen your thinking
Talk your idea through with a partner. Use the conversation to test whether the conflict feels specific, nuanced, and narratively alive.
Why is this truly a dilemma, not just a correct-or-incorrect choice?
What does each possible choice reveal about the character?
What larger theme or human question could this conflict open up?
My partner pushed my thinking by saying
5
Draft My Central Dilemma Statement
this becomes the core of your chapter
Write one strong sentence that captures the conflict at the center of your chapter. It should be clear enough to guide your writing, but layered enough to hold emotional and ethical complexity.
Protecting a relationship vs. compromising the truthSafety, belonging, and responsibility collidedEvery available choice had consequences
My superpower I will use to address this dilemma is:
My superpower belongs to:
Choose the PeaceVerse universe connected to your superpower.
💚HeartVerse
Caring, belonging, courage, and emotional safety
🧠MindVerse
Thinking, learning, creativity, and wise choices
💛EmpathyVerse
Understanding others, working together, and helping people
⚖️JusticeVerse
Fairness, responsibility, and building a better future
Visualize the chapter image
✏️Sketch the scene, symbol, or image that best represents this dilemma
0% complete · start anywhere!